Up Your Holiday Cookie Game

Up Your Holiday Cookie Game

Publish Date December 5, 2024 1 Minute Read
Author MyMagazine Staff

Use a toothpick and icing to create stunning designs.

Overhead view of 1 large white bowl of white royal icing surrounded by 4 smaller bowls of royal icing, dyed red, blue, green and yellow.

Dye the Icing

Whip up a batch of icing. Keeping half white, divide the other half into smaller bowls and tint portions with contrasting colors. Keep it festive — think reds, greens, golds or blues for the holidays.

A square sugar cookie on a white mar-ble surface. Piping tip is applying a base layer of blue royal icing.

Create a Canvas

Apply a base coat of Royal Icing (this can be white or a color) to a cookie. Make sure it’s even since this will be your canvas.

A square sugar cookie on a white marble surface with blue base icing. Piping tip is applying a series of yellow icing lines overtop.

Start the Design

Before the icing base begins to dry, use a contrasting color to pipe lines, small hash marks or dots overtop. Be creative — these are the patterns your toothpick will enhance.

A series of three images of single sugar cookies showing how to use the toothpick method to decorate. The first image shows using the feathered look, the middle image shows the wreath method and the third image shows the marble method.

It’s Toothpick Time

While the icing is still wet, drag a toothpick through the icing to make your own designs. Swirl, swoop and wow with different dragging techniques:

  1. Drag a toothpick perpendicular to icing lines, alternating directions, for a feathered or swirled look.
  2. Drag a toothpick through icing hash marks around the perimeter of a circle cookie to create a wreath.
  3. Drag a toothpick through icing dots in random directions for a marbled masterpiece.
A variety of decorated sugar cookies, using the toothpick icing method, on a white marble surface.

Let Icing Dry

Give the icing time to set — no nibbles yet! Once dry, admire your handiwork before these cookies become the star of your holiday platter — or the envy of the cookie exchange.

Shop Holiday Cookie Ingredients